Skip to main content

Shortlands

Evidence

Definition: the material by which facts in dispute are proved to the court. It includes documents, witness statements, oral testimony, expert reports, photographs, recordings, and admissions.

The family court is more flexible than the criminal courts about admissibility, and can admit hearsay. What matters is weight rather than exclusion. The standard of proof in family proceedings is the balance of probabilities: whether a fact is more likely than not to be true. The burden falls on the party who asserts the fact. Findings are binary; a fact is either proved or it is not, and a fact not proved is treated as not having happened.

Related Questions:

What is the standard of proof? The balance of probabilities, meaning more likely than not.

Can I use covert recordings? Sometimes, but the court takes a dim view of covert recording of children and of professionals, and it frequently damages the recording party’s case more than the other side’s.

Who has to prove what? The person making an allegation bears the burden of proving it. There is no obligation on the other party to disprove it.

What if the judge cannot decide? The allegation is not proved and is treated as not having occurred. There is no middle ground.

BOOK AN APPOINTMENT

Please fill the form below to arrange your fixed cost initial appointment.

    REQUEST A CALL BACK

    Please fill the form below to request a free call back: