Skip to main content

Shortlands

Case Law

Definition: the body of law derived from decisions of the courts, as distinct from statute made by Parliament. Under the doctrine of precedent, the reasoning necessary to a decision of a higher court binds lower courts in later cases with materially similar facts.

Family law is heavily shaped by case law. The governing statutes set out broad factors to be weighed rather than rules to be applied, and it is the reported decisions that give those factors content: what sharing means, when needs justify departing from equality, how conduct is treated, when a trust is a resource.

Related Questions:

What is the difference between case law and statute? Statute is enacted by Parliament. Case law is created by judges deciding cases, and interprets and applies the statute.

Does a judge have to follow earlier cases? A judge must follow the binding reasoning of a higher court. Decisions of courts at the same or lower level are persuasive but not binding.

Why does family law rely so heavily on case law? Because the statutory framework confers a broad discretion. The factors the court must consider are listed, but their relative weight has been worked out through litigation.

Can case law change? Yes. Higher courts can depart from earlier decisions, and Parliament can override case law by legislation.

BOOK AN APPOINTMENT

Please fill the form below to arrange your fixed cost initial appointment.

    REQUEST A CALL BACK

    Please fill the form below to request a free call back: